Chile

The case concerned the enforced disappearance of a detainee during the period immediately following the 1973 military coup led by Augusto Pinochet in Chile. The requested person, a former military officer, was sought for prosecution in connection with the kidnapping, detention, torture and disappearance of the victim, who was never found. The defence argued that the offence was time-barred under both Italian and Chilean law and that the requested person had merely followed superior orders. The Court held that the historical facts amounted to a complex criminal conduct equivalent, under Italian law, to kidnapping combined with voluntary homicide and constituting crimes against humanity not subject to statutory limitation periods. It further found sufficient evidentiary material linking the requested person to the victim’s unlawful detention and disappearance and therefore declared the conditions for extradition to Chile fulfilled.